Troubles with Getting Mental Health Help and Insurance
What is mental illness? Mental illness is hard to understand and describe. If you don’t have it, there is a variety of ways in which you might view it. Some see it as a disability that can be overcome with determination. Some see it as make believe, meant to draw attention. Others see it as what it is, an illness. An illness, that while not visible to the naked eye, that is just as dangerous, if not more dangerous, than a physical illness, if it is left untreated. But how do people who suffer from it, view it?
In the case of an anonymous Buzzfeed reader who suffers from Bipolar Disorder, “mania isn’t fun or simply being hyper and happy. There’s that ‘sweet spot’ you hit before everything goes out of control where you’re productive, extroverted, chatty, creative, you feel great and at the top of your game — but it’s not like that all the time. It spirals out of control pretty quickly. You’re irritable and angry and paranoid. You spend too much money, you drive recklessly, you put yourself in compromising situations, you act out sexually, you can’t stop talking. You don’t sleep. You become obsessive, you start to see and hear things. And going from such an extreme high to such an extreme low is exhausting.”
In the case of Julia La Bonte, another Buzzfeed reader who suffers from Bipolar Disorder, “when I’m having a manic episode, I’m unstoppable. Mania inspires me to pick up new hobbies, like knitting or couponing, just to drop it all the second my manic episode has ended. In the beginning of a manic episode, it just feels like a productive day. It starts off with me doing everything I’m supposed to without much effort. But then I’m up at 3 a.m. reorganizing my closet even though I have to be at work early. When I’m manic, I don’t feel bipolar. My mania feels like success. It feels like I’m finally doing everything right and nothing can go wrong. Casey Gueren. “Here’s What It’s Actually Like To Live With Bipolar Disorder” 21 Apr. 2016. Accessed 27 Feb. 2019. https://www.buzzfeed.com/caseygueren/bipolar-disorder.
In the latter case, you can see the productive, “good side” of Bipolar disorder. In the former, you can see what that “good side” eventually leads towards. But like Julia says, when you’re in the “good side”, you don’t realize it. You don’t realize that what you feel isn’t real. You don’t realize that the way you act, while it feels completely normal, rational and reasonable to you, might seem weird, off putting, eccentric, even scary and many other negative things to others. There’s no magic switch or alarm that lets those who suffer from it know when they are in a manic or depressive episode, or if one might be coming. All they know, is that eventually, it will arrive and in most cases, it will cause damage to the person who suffers from it and the people who are in the blast radius of it.
What helps? Well, according to another Buzzfeed reader who suffers from Bipolar disorder, it “is a chemical imbalance in the brain that we were born with. Despite popular belief, bipolar patients can have a normal life. They can have a spouse, children, and a successful career. I achieved all of those things through cognitive behavioral therapy, medication, and an indomitable spirit.”
There are others echoing that sentiment(they can be read here: https://www.buzzfeed.com/caseygueren/bipolar-disorder) of therapy, medication and self belief. Unfortunately, it is hard to make someone who is suffering from Bipolar disorder, or any mental illness, believe that the suffering is temporary and that it can be overcome. However, if the person can be convinced to try a strict regimen of taking their medication and going to therapy, the belief will come.
In most cases of mental disorders, the feeling of hopelessness and the lack of belief comes from the disorder lying to you and tricking you. Medication is what reduces the effects of the disorder and allows you to see things clearly and rationally. Look at the case of Reddit user and Bipolar disorder sufferer empty packages, who went off their medication: warning, disturbing and shocking content.“A Friendly Reminder To Not Go Off Your Meds.” Reddit. Accessed March 05, 2019. https://www.reddit.com/r/BipolarReddit/comments/ad74cp/a_friendly_reminder_to_not_go_off_your_meds/?st=jsw9yjki&sh=11448017
A quick google search will show hundreds and thousands of similar posts. Not just for Bipolar disorder, but for all kinds of mental illnesses. The unfortunate, high-profile deaths of superstars such as Avicii, Anthony Bourdain and Verne Troyer(among others) in the last year, has led to an increase in attention from the general public towards mental illness. However, there is still not enough attention being paid.
Here are some sobering facts, courtesy of National Alliance on Mental Illness“Mental Health By The Numbers.” NAMI: National Alliance on Mental Illness. Accessed March 05, 2019. https://www.nami.org/learn-more/mental-health-by-the-numbers: 43.8 million Americans, at any given time, suffer from a mental illness. Out of the 20.2 million adults in the U.S. who have a substance use disorder, 50.5%, 10.2 million, suffer from a mental illness. 70% of those in juvenile justice systems, have at least one mental illness. Untreated American adults who suffer from a serious mental disorder, on average, tend to die 25 years earlier than others. Suicide is the 10th leading cause of death in America. Every day, between 18 and 22 veterans die by suicide.
So, what is mental illness? It doesn’t matter. What matters is that it is affecting everyone. If not directly, then by seeing someone you know or love being affected by it. It is an issue that needs to be tackled. We are no longer in the dark ages of psychiatry, where electroshock therapy and insane asylums are the only courses of action. We now have a variety of behavioral health treatments available. As you can see from the examples in the Buzzfeed article, it is absolutely possible to have a mental illness and still live a full life. Now the mission is to reduce the stigma around mental illness and encourage those who need help to reach out and ask for and get it.
But, how do we ensure that the people who need it, get the best care possible? According to an article in ForbesJapsen, Bruce. “Psychiatrist Shortage Escalates As U.S. Mental Health Needs Grow.” Forbes. February 26, 2018. Accessed March 07, 2019 https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucejapsen/2018/02/25/psychiatrist-shortage-escalates-as-u-s-mental-health-needs-grow/#16f296fc1255, there are 28 thousand psychiatrists in the United States. Yet, people are unable to get help with behavioral health issues. Why?
One of the biggest reasons that those in need of help with their mental health don’t get it, is because of the difficulty finding a behavior health practitioner who takes insurance. Take for instance the case of Emily Taylor. After a break-up, Emily experienced anxiety and depression. When she tried to find help, she was unable to do so due to finding it difficult to find a behavioral health practitioner who took her Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield insurance plan(the second most used health insurance plan in the United States, with nearly 40 million subscribers)Migneault, Jesse. “Top 5 Largest Health Insurance Payers in the United States.” HealthPayerIntelligence. April 13, 2017. Accessed March 11, 2019. https://healthpayerintelligence.com/news/top-5-largest-health-insurance-payers-in-the-united-states.
According to Emily, she “spent days looking for therapists near me that were covered by my insurance, for the very few I did find, I spent over five hours on the phone trying to get appointments, to find that they were either not accepting new patients or the wait time was two months.” Emily was able to locate several behavioral health specialists, however, in New York, they would cost between $200 and $300 per session.Pajer, Nicole. “Why Is Therapy So Expensive?” HuffPost. May 19, 2017. Accessed March 11, 2019. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/therapy-expensive-insurance_n_5900048ee4b0af6d718992e7
The more you look for an answer in this situation, the more questions you find. For instance, why is the cost of getting mental health care so expensive? The insurance companies’ reimbursement rates are much lower than the rate that is charged regularly. This leads to the behavioral health practitioners not having much of an incentive to work with insurance companies. Furthermore, due to the difference in the way they practice medicine, behavioral health practitioners, unlike primary care doctors, don’t have a dedicated staff to do the insurance paperwork, which in and of itself is a full time job.
One way to work around this issue would be to have an electronic health records (EHR) system, used by almost all healthcare practitioners, that also does insurance filing. While it might seem absurd to subscribe to an EHR service, instead of hiring an assistant, to help with filing insurance, the EHR would serve multiple uses and it would serve those uses much faster than an assistant could.
Take the case of Dr. Johnson. She says that thanks to accepting insurance, her patient load and schedule are maxed out and her practice is thriving. In a situation like this, an EHR that is built specifically for behavioral health care would be perfect, since it would be able to help people like Dr. Johnson keep track of their schedule, find patient charts quickly, take notes faster, keep track of payment and file insurance forms.
However, even with these possible steps, getting someone proper help with their mental health might be hard. Insurance companies view mental health much differently than other health problems. As Dr. Ackerman noted, “insurance companies tend to see things more from a medical perspective ― where if you get sick, for example, when you take a blood test, they figure out what is wrong with you, they give you a medication and then you are all better, but with mental health, a lot of times what we are trying to do is preventative maintenance-type work, and it makes it a lot more difficult to justify medical necessity with insurance companies.”
For now, there seems to be no reforms or changes to be expected in the near future as it pertains to this situation. The number of people who suffer from mental health illness is rising and despite the large number of behavioral health practitioners, there isn’t enough access to proper mental health care. As more and more awareness is being raised about mental health and its importance, the hope for the future is that the healthcare and insurance industries will adapt and evolve enough that this article would be considered a fossil.
|1.||Casey Gueren. “Here’s What It’s Actually Like To Live With Bipolar Disorder” 21 Apr. 2016. Accessed 27 Feb. 2019. https://www.buzzfeed.com/caseygueren/bipolar-disorder.|
|2.||“A Friendly Reminder To Not Go Off Your Meds.” Reddit. Accessed March 05, 2019. https://www.reddit.com/r/BipolarReddit/comments/ad74cp/a_friendly_reminder_to_not_go_off_your_meds/?st=jsw9yjki&sh=11448017|
|3.||“Mental Health By The Numbers.” NAMI: National Alliance on Mental Illness. Accessed March 05, 2019. https://www.nami.org/learn-more/mental-health-by-the-numbers|
|4.||Japsen, Bruce. “Psychiatrist Shortage Escalates As U.S. Mental Health Needs Grow.” Forbes. February 26, 2018. Accessed March 07, 2019 https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucejapsen/2018/02/25/psychiatrist-shortage-escalates-as-u-s-mental-health-needs-grow/#16f296fc1255|
|5.||Migneault, Jesse. “Top 5 Largest Health Insurance Payers in the United States.” HealthPayerIntelligence. April 13, 2017. Accessed March 11, 2019. https://healthpayerintelligence.com/news/top-5-largest-health-insurance-payers-in-the-united-states|
|6.||Pajer, Nicole. “Why Is Therapy So Expensive?” HuffPost. May 19, 2017. Accessed March 11, 2019. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/therapy-expensive-insurance_n_5900048ee4b0af6d718992e7|
- Patient Histories: The Key to Quality CareOct 01 , 2019
- 3A’s (Aggregate, Analyze and Act) of Healthcare ITSep 19 , 2019
- Telemedicine – Benefits and ChallengesSep 04 , 2019
- Health Data Exchange StandardsJul 31 , 2019
- Telehealth: Technology meets HealthcareApr 11 , 2019
- Integrated Care: The Future of Behavioral HealthMar 29 , 2019
- Troubles with Getting Mental Health Help and InsuranceMar 15 , 2019
- 7 Things to do to Protect Against Ransomware AttacksAug 08 , 2018
- Oh EHR, how can we love thee?Apr 20 , 2018
- What’s in Store for Practice Fusion UsersJan 31 , 2018
- What is precision medicine? And how can EHR help?Jan 05 , 2018
- What’s the SOAPware alternative?Dec 15 , 2017
- Artificial Intelligence, EHRs and the future of health technologyNov 02 , 2017
- ACA Executive order’s impact on EMR and eHealth technologyOct 25 , 2017
- EHRs and Mental Health: What Needs to Change?Sep 29 , 2017
- American Medical Association (And Others) Unhappy With EHR ProvidersSep 22 , 2017
- A Celebration of Citizenship DaySep 18 , 2017
- Amazon’s Stealthy Foray Into the World of EHRAug 18 , 2017
- Google, the Gender Gap and Personal ResponsibilityAug 10 , 2017
- Neal Patterson and the Mission of Health ITJul 21 , 2017
- The Myth About Motivating People To PerformJul 14 , 2017
- Fragmented health data and personalized medicine: What to do?Jul 07 , 2017
- Apple’s Venture Into the World of EHR SoftwareJun 23 , 2017
- What does the U.K. health record hack mean for eHealth security?Jun 15 , 2017
- Why Doctors need an All-rounder Healthcare Solution?Mar 19 , 2016
- Are we ready for data-driven healthcare?Mar 12 , 2016
- Using Medicare And Private Sector Claims Data for Patient care QualityFeb 26 , 2016
- The Doctor must “Evolve” with the TechnologyFeb 26 , 2016
- The 2015 Practice Profitability IndexFeb 25 , 2016
- ‘Mind Your Risks’ – The NIH health campaignFeb 22 , 2016
- Middle East and Arab Health 2016Feb 03 , 2016
- Medical Billing in 2016Jan 08 , 2016
- CMS publishes 2014 National Health ExpendituresJan 02 , 2016
- Results from the Practice Profitability Index 2015Dec 16 , 2015
- This National Diabetes Month, you have a role in diabetes education and supportNov 26 , 2015
- Safe Texting in HealthCare: Do’s & Dont’sNov 18 , 2015
- Is TeleMedicine the future of healthcare ?Nov 13 , 2015
- Evaluating specific KPIs can improve business performanceNov 09 , 2015
- 50 Years of Medicare: More than 55 million Americans covered by MedicareSep 23 , 2015
- How Much Does Healthcare Cost Matter To A Patient?Sep 18 , 2015
- How does Affordable Care Act Change Your Practice?Sep 11 , 2015
- A ‘Don’t Do’ List to avoid patient no-showsAug 21 , 2015
- Add more patients and grow your medical business in 5 easy stepsAug 05 , 2015
- Medicare Trust Fund is now protected by the Fraud Prevention SystemJul 16 , 2015
- ICD-10: A Short StoryMay 19 , 2015
- Patient portals and patient engagement: Is there a link?Apr 21 , 2015
- Meaningful Use Stage 3: First LookApr 07 , 2015
- 6 Ways Physicians can Free Patient RecordsMar 17 , 2015
- Is the EHR market saturated?Dec 04 , 2014
- 5 Benefits of healthcare information exchanges for small practicesApr 22 , 2014
- New Study shows EMR Adoption Increases Patient Confidence, Loyalty and SatisfactionApr 22 , 2014
- Cloud-Based EMR Vendors and Patient Data SecurityApr 22 , 2014